The Reverend William H. Roth
June 23, 1912 - 1917

The Reverend H. L. Thomas
June 1, 1918 – September 6, 1918

The Reverend B. S. Dise
March 15, 1919 - February 1, 1921

The Reverend L. H. Hasselbacher
December 18, 1921 – September 30, 1923

The Reverend Fred W. Heins
October 22, 1923 - June 15, 1924

The Reverend F. H. Seaman
October 12, 1924

The Reverend Smith, The Reverend Agnew and The Reverend William Peters during the years 1925 to 1927

The Reverend Frederick Wunder
March 20, 1928 - May, 1929

The Reverend Otto C. F. Janke
December 29, 1929 - April 9, 1933

The Reverend Paul H. Sheffer
June 25, 1937 - August 31, 1936

The Reverend Raymond Foellner
January 13, 1937 – September 10, 1952

The Reverend Samuel M. Clarke
December 1952 - December 31, 1965

The Reverend David G. Krewson, Jr.
June 26, 1966 – June 2000

The Reverend Steven Caler
April 2002 – June 2003

The Reverend Nancy B. Brown
November 30, 2003 – Present